Tuesday, November 3, 2009

Prophesies and Postdiction

A prophesy is the foretelling of future events. A postdiction is the effort of trying to fit events into a foretold prophesy.

A prophesy may be from God. But a postdiction is 100% man-made.


I am very skeptical of religious figures who claim to have the 'gift' of prophecy. I believe God does not simply give this gift to many people. Only the selected few get this gift. Not every pastor , priest or holy man is a prophet.

There are many fake prophets in history , notably Nostradamus.

How to recognise real prophesy from postdiction?

A real prophesy is very specific - with specific names , date , time place

It is not open-ended or ambigious. Ambigious prophecies are fake prophesies which try to play safe by being non-specific.

Postdiction are the following :

1. Vague  with no specific time , date , place , or even the event.
     "A disaster will happen in future .. "
     Disasters always happen yearly or even monthly.

2. Open-ended - with no specific time and date
     "In future , this will .. "

3. Recycled over and over again.
  • Enthusiasts often tries to fit the most current event to the prophecy that has been used again and again in the past.

4. Cover all possibility
  • The use of "may" , "might" , "could" which can turn out to be "may not","might not" and "cannot"
       " If you do this , you might ... "  or might not.

5. Shotgunning - shooting many targets so that at least one would be struck.
     "In 2010, a certain leader would raise up .. "

6. Statistically-likely - very high probability of happening
    "There will be an accident on xyz highway this morning .. "

7. Unfalsified - Hard to verify
    "When he was born, lotus plants appear wherever he placed his feet.."

8. Counting the hits not the misses - over-focusing on the few successful predictions but ignoring the many misses.

9. Allegory - claiming that it's not the physical but the 'spiritual'
    A 'prophet' may predict the death of someone famous. But when he did not die, the explanation given that he did experience 'spiritual death'


10. Moving the goal post.
      "God decided to grant you a second chance .. so He changed His mind.."


11. Conditional 'prophesies' - prophecies keep changing because 'certain conditions' are not met 

     "Your sickness will be healed by October" But when it did not happen, the explanation given is "Your prophesy did not materialize because you did not do this and that .."

12. 'Prophesies' from psychological and emotional evaluations
     We can, for a certain extent, predict what a person is like from his appearance, behaviour and speech. If a person is always anxious, we could predict that he is in fear of something etc. A shabbily-dressed person is most often a person who has a lackadaisical attitude towards many things.

Adapted from :
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Postdiction

No comments:

Post a Comment